Then I baked them for 6 minutes and let them cool a minute on the pan before removing them. I made them a little on the small side, and rolled the balls in sugar before my 4yo made the criss-cross pattern with the fork. I didn't refrigerate the dough at all, and didn't really feel like I needed to. And, I used all natural creamy peanut butter. So, I decided to try this one, and it was really good! I only made half a batch, because we were low on peanut butter. I have made peanut butter cookies MANY times, but the recipe that I always use is in storage. Scroll through for 20 ideas of what to eat with tomato soup, including simple salads, twice-baked potatoes, and, of course, grilled cheese sandwiches. Or, kick the indulgence factor up a notch and opt for heartier foods, such as mozzarella sticks, risotto, potatoes, or even meatloaf. Lighter sides, such as green salads, can hold their own against tomato soup without compromising its flavor. The key is to work with foods that will complement tomato soup's trademark acidic and slightly sweet notes. However, as the existence of the grilled cheese sandwich proves, tomato soup is always better when it's served alongside a contrasting dish or dipping vehicle. 18 Recipes to Eat With Tomato Soup Simple yet satisfying, tomato soup is one of the most classic comfort foods around.